Thursday, September 29, 2011

Hindus and Sikhs Unite

Monday, September 18, 2006

RE: Rashtrya Sikh Sangat on VANDE MATRAM – Part I

To: Respected Prime Minister Sri Man Mohan Singh, & Respected Members of Parliament, News Media, Intelligentsia & Friends around the world:

An unholy alliance, anti-national, appears to be taking place; Indian Muslims and Sikhs are (unfairly) singing in unison: We object to Vande-Matram, the national song.
Please don't forget: our Bhagat Singh Shahid. I am sure, dear Sikh brothers, he stands ten feet taller, a better Sikh than we all. Bhagat Singh sang this patriotic song, rankling the Imperial British administration of India. This happened in my lifetime. Bhagat Singh is not alone. Kavasheer, Sampuran Singh (of Punjab), Bhai Dyal Das, Haqikat Rai (the Sikh Bahadur), Baba Dip Singh Bahadur, Baba Gurbaksh Singh, Baba Ram Singh Bedi, Baba Ram Singh Kuka, Baba Trilochan Singh (I could keep citing more names) happily roared Vande-Matram. This made our enemy more nervous.

Finally by 1942-47, enemy was so nervous, decided to quit India, and India got independence, thanks to our united and patriotic singing of Vande-Matram.

There is no Sikh religious objection; Bhagat Singh as well as Baba Deep Singh made it very clear; all Sikhs are not Akali; Mona Sikhs (even when they follow the ten Gurus 100%) continue to stress that we Sikhs are a Hindu sect, - that we are loyal to Hinduism (also called Bharat-Mata).

I have been to Iran; Iranian Muslim youth were singing Madre - Watan. Now give me your reply. In Farsi language, Madre-Watan, the mother land is worth bowing to (our parents, as per Vedic culture, Iranian culture included, bow unhesitantly to our mother land and pledge to defend it from the external enemies.

The Egyptian case comes to mind. The Arab Islam was trying to defeat the Egyptian patriotism (Egyptian Coptics, the defenders sang Mother Egypt). The Arab attackers were very savage and barbaric. They threw up the Coptic babies in the air, catching them on their spears on the rebound. These babies were thus threaded on to the sharp-edged spears with instant death. Why so much cruelty on the innocent children? IS THIS YOUR WAY OF EXPLAINING ISLAM THE PEACEFUL RELIGION!

Jehad: You tell the Kafirs, you have no right to be Hindu or Sikh or Farsi Zardushti: “Convert to Islam instantly or be beheaded.” Is this the peaceful Islam or the live and let live coexistence?

With Jihad as Islamic tenet, it gives Islam the liberty to become Al-Caponic (an American Mafia, Chicago gangster) gangster, terrorizing the Hindu or Christian neighbor. Who can give you this right in a non-Muslim country, like USA? Jehad is totally unacceptable in any modern nation. It should not be legal even in Muslim majority countries. The non-Muslims have the right to practice their religion peacefully unchallenged; This is the UNO. World Charter... no religious persecution just because we are non-Muslims.

Every year, Pakistan has a case, a Christian youth is about to be lynched. No modern country in the world should terrorize its minority and the Muslim majority must let their non-Muslim minority practice their religion as first class citizen.

The Muslim practice is to the contrary: In Malaysia and Bangladesh, Hindu temples are being systematically destroyed, not the adjacent mosques. We tell such Jehadis: Stop terrorizing the peaceful Buddhists or Hindus or else stop claiming yourself to be "A Peaceful Islam."

Islam spread in the world through sword and cruelty, not through peace. Islam suppressed the conquered Buddhists (the whole Central Asia later called Turkistan) savagely.

In India, Islam fights not to let Hindus revive their Ram temple, but in reverse, totally unrepentant that Islam destroyed 3,000 temples and forcibly made these into mosques (why do you claim Islam means Peace and Shalom?).

You staged a (forced) game on the Buddhists..... two circles, inner and outer. The inner circle is of Buddhists, they must keep circling, dancing, even if they are tired. If and when they give up, they move to outer circle, which indicates: O.K. I am converting willy-nilly to Islam. All this time, the inner circle was being flogged by the Muslim Jehadis. In Egypt, the Coptics were unallowed to speak Coptic language. Arab language came as an outside imposition by the Arab invaders. Neither by language nor by blood, the Egyptian are Arab per se.

Now you moved into Iran and the terror finished the Zurdushti religion & culture. The Iranian police beat the native girl, if not in burqa. In Turkey however, Kamal Pasha encouraged the dropping of Arabic language or culture. You can see unveiled lady engineer, a pilot, an attorney or a judge. Now the world scholars are predicting - you are extending the game of denationalizing on the Western world. This means, Islam is not a religion, it is Arabic imperialism, political as well as socio-culturally. Europe or USA may wake up but it might be too late, as was the case with many others. Spain recovered - just in time.

Well, back to our Sikh saint Baba Faqir Chand of Sialkot district (pre-partitioned Punjab, his village named Kotli Faqir Chand. Tradition credits Baba Faqir Chand with possessions of miraculous powers, hence venerated by the public.

Later, his son, Ram Singh Bedi would rise to the same level of veneration. The villain in this history, Shahanchi Khan was cruel in contrast, having a persistent habit of savage cruelty towards peaceful Sikhs and Hindus of Sialkot area. He would go to Hindus & Sikhs homes, his goons promptly beheaded the males and kidnapped the women and girls for rape and for sale as slave (in Kabul market). The freshly cut Hindu/Sikh heads were placed on hot griddles (the beads would dance thus on the griddle).

After the old father Faqir Chand’s martydom, Baba Ram Singh started the counterattack, to make the cruel Shahanchi Khan stop this barbaric savagery. Both sides grew large; Khan’s army up to 30,000 Jehadis and the patriotic defense up to 8,000 volunteers. To make it in brief, despite heavy odds, the patriots won the day; Shahanchi Khan got killed while fighting and non-Muslims heaved a sigh of relief. We can ascertain this piece of history (BOOK: History of Punjab: Author Mohammed Latif, the historian).

Peaceful Nanak Dev (1439-1533) heart bled at the thought of mass scale Muslim savagery in India. Says he: “The age of sword and rules are butches Muslim virtue had taken wings and fled the dark night of Amavas has enveloped the moon of Truth and Justice and Indians look for fair men and coexistence in vain.”

CONCLUSION: There is nothing wrong with Vande Matram, India’s sacred slogan. WE MUST LEARN NOW: “UNITED WE STAND TOGETHER– DIVIDED WE FALL.”

This article is dedicated by Dr. Lalsingh Sardana, Houston, Texas, USA. All replies must be addressed to: Rashtrya Sikh Sangat 4114 Graymercy, Houston, Texas 77025 , USA

Wednesday, August 17, 2011

इतना फॉरवर्ड करो की एक आन्दोलन बन जाये

280 लाख करोड़ का सवाल है ...
भारतीय गरीब है लेकिन भारत देश कभी गरीब नहीं रहा"* ये कहना है स्विस बैंक के डाइरेक्टर का. स्विस बैंक के डाइरेक्टर ने यह भी कहा है कि भारत का लगभग 280 लाख करोड़ रुपये उनके स्विस बैंक में जमा है. ये रकम इतनी है कि भारत का आने वाले 30 सालों का बजट बिना टैक्स के बनाया जा सकता है.

या यूँ कहें कि 60 करोड़ रोजगार के अवसर दिए जा सकते है. या यूँ भी कह सकते है कि भारत के किसी भी गाँव से दिल्ली तक 4 लेन रोड बनाया जा सकता है.

ऐसा भी कह सकते है कि 500 से ज्यादा सामाजिक प्रोजेक्ट पूर्ण किये जा सकते है. ये रकम इतनी ज्यादा है कि अगर हर भारतीय को 2000 रुपये हर महीने भी दिए जाये तो 60 साल तक ख़त्म ना हो. यानी भारत को किसी वर्ल्ड बैंक से लोन लेने कि कोई जरुरत नहीं है. जरा सोचिये ... हमारे भ्रष्ट राजनेताओं और नोकरशाहों ने कैसे देश को

लूटा है और ये लूट का सिलसिला अभी तक 2011 तक जारी है.

इस सिलसिले को अब रोकना बहुत ज्यादा जरूरी हो गया है. अंग्रेजो ने हमारे भारत पर करीब 200 सालो तक राज करके करीब 1 लाख करोड़ रुपये लूटा.

मगर आजादी के केवल 64 सालों में हमारे भ्रस्टाचार ने 280 लाख करोड़ लूटा है. एक तरफ 200 साल में 1 लाख करोड़ है और दूसरी तरफ केवल 64 सालों में 280 लाख करोड़ है. यानि हर साल लगभग 4.37 लाख करोड़, या हर महीने करीब 36 हजार करोड़ भारतीय मुद्रा स्विस बैंक में इन भ्रष्ट लोगों द्वारा जमा करवाई गई है.

भारत को किसी वर्ल्ड बैंक के लोन की कोई दरकार नहीं है. सोचो की कितना पैसा हमारे भ्रष्ट राजनेताओं और उच्च अधिकारीयों ने ब्लाक करके रखा हुआ है.

हमे भ्रस्ट राजनेताओं और भ्रष्ट अधिकारीयों के खिलाफ जाने का पूर्ण अधिकार है.हाल ही में हुवे घोटालों का आप सभी को पता ही है - CWG घोटाला, २ जी स्पेक्ट्रुम घोटाला , आदर्श होउसिंग घोटाला ... और ना जाने कौन कौन से घोटाले अभी उजागर होने वाले है ........

आप लोग जोक्स फॉरवर्ड करते ही हो.
इसे भी इतना फॉरवर्ड करो की पूरा भारत इसे पढ़े ... और एक आन्दोलन बन जाये

“दर्द होता रहा छटपटाते रहे,
आईने॒से सदा चोट खाते रहे,
वो वतन बेचकर मुस्कुराते रहे “

Saturday, July 30, 2011

The Sikhs and 1947

The Eyewitness. On this point, the witness Niranjan Singh, a Sikh, testified. Singh, a few weeks ago a prosperous merchant in the Montgomery district of the Punjab, now moves about New Delhi on crutches. He said:
"I shall never rest until revenge is taken upon the Moslems for all the wicked atrocities they have perpetrated upon innocent people. Moslems killed my old father, abducted my young daughter, slew my son and maimed my foot. No mercy whatsoever should be shown to them. I've always treated my Moslem laborers with kindness but the dirty swine have repaid me with brutality.
"I smelled trouble in my village when Moslems began gathering at the mosque every day for long conferences. One morning Moslems from all neighboring areas gathered around our village and attacked it. But although we were outnumbered, we held them for eight hours. We had only our kirpans [swords] and a few old rifles. They had modern weapons. When finally they broke through, there was not one among us who had not sustained some injury or other. The brutes killed my 90-year-old father and when my young son rushed to his defense, they speared him to death. I had been injured on my forehead and gushing blood had made me partly blind. A young, cowardly Moslem attacked me from behind with a hatchet, injuring my foot. Before I fell and fainted, I saw some Moslems carrying away my 16-year-old daughter, who put up stiff resistance.

Jinnah is far too easy a villain: conceivably an obsessed child of Mohamed conceivably a man seized in his declining years by that most dangerous form of satyriasis which longs for naked power alone, Jinnah has beyond question done more than any other man in India to exacerbate the sores of communalism and to tease and torment their rawness; and this purely to secure his nation, and a torn body for India.

Tara Singh gave this grisly forecast an algebraic twist. He pointed out that fleeing Sikhs (who are richer) had left six million acres of land, while an equal number of fleeing Moslems had left only two million acres. His proposal: drive enough Moslems from their farms to balance the property exchange.

Read more:,9171,854810,00.html#ixzz1Tcla2x1A

Friday, July 22, 2011

Joshua Project in India

The Joshua project is a US project backed by the CIA to identify groups of peoples unreached by the Gospel. It was established in 1989 and it first major "field trial" was in North India below is an extract from the book "The Armies of God a study of militant Christianity by Ian Buchanan (Citizens International)

"......Northern India was considered by the AD2000 organizers to be a key region for attention. It was where modern evangelism began, with William Carey,some 200 years ago. But it has immense significance today as one of the most poverty stricken parts of India (the Hindi speaking belt has a literacy rate of jut 30%, and an infant mortality rate double the national) It also the heartland of also has the smallest christian population in all of India just 0.5%.

The structure included World Vision Gospel for Asia US government agencies and unwitting local partners, like the Indian Missions association the Indian Postal Service, Indian Immigration Department.....the three acronyms to describe the strategy are:

1. PLUG People in every Language,Urban centre,Geographic division;
2. PREM Prayer Research, Evangelisation,and Mobilization
3. NICE Networking;Initiative;use Evangelists to spur existing Cohorts in an effort . to convert.

Sunday, July 17, 2011

Overseas Friends of India UK 16/7/11 meet

Overseas Friends of BJP meeting in London I attended, there was great warmth between UK Friends of BJP and excellent speechs were made of the way to advance Bharat by the BJP President. I meet with many dignitaries from Bharat. The views of this blog are my own opinions and have no connection with BJP official policy.

Friday, July 15, 2011

The Wests Attack on Hindus by 6 Apps

I entirely agree with your feelings about treatment given to Hindus, their culture, traditions as well as and their temples by the powers that be. And in spite of the fact that they form majority in Bhaarat.
Kindly refer to the book "Civilization: The West and The Rest" written by the Harvard historian, Shri Niall Ferguson. He mentions the six 'killer' applications (to State Craft) patented by The West since last 600 years and offered to the rest (other communities & civilizations). He shows in his thick book that West has killed all other civilizations and made those communities accept West thoroughly, because of the quality of the West Civilization. I have written an article "Applications Offered by The West" based on whatever material on the book was available to me. I have compared West with The Bhaarateey culture and philosophy to show that these six applications are in fact Killers of the communities as well as the cultures of the communities. But Bhaarateey culture is made up of sterner stuff to overcome the assault by the West. Currently because of the primacy given by The West to Money and physical enjoyment of man, the stage appears to have come for its own demise.The six applications mentioned by Shri Ferguson are Competition, Modern Science, Rule of Law and Property Rights, Work Ethics, Modern Medicine and Consumerism.
Laws which were given by Dharm were denied by the State and initiated its own laws passed by the legislators. They were in writing therefore susceptible to (mis)interpretation to suit the objectives of the lawyers. The judges were barred from considering anything else except the aspects (of the cases) brought before them by the lawyers. With these two specialties and limitations in the dispensation of the laws became complicated resulting in deterioration of the relationships in the communities. That is the reason Mahatma Gandhi had said in his book 'Hind-Swaraaj' written in 1908 that the profession of Lawyers has been promulgated by the British to destroy the mutual faith in Bhaarateey people's minds. This is what is being manifested now.
What we are seeing in the culmination of plan devised and continuously unfolded over the sixty odd years to denigrate Hindu faith in the country. A way to install the unity amongst Bhaarateey people has been suggested in the article "A Vedic Response to Terrorism" written by me (along with Dr Leffler of USA) a couple of years back. Recently it has been published in new version under the title "Invincible Defence Technology" by 'Indian Defence Consultants'

Monday, July 11, 2011

Ideas for a Hindu Raj

remove this govt urgently by hindu unity force. hindus must prsuade some borderline desh drohi party to divorce this govt n topple it on this very serious hindu killer issue.
get hindus all their religious rights
1- hindu men woman should get arms to carry like thier devi devtacarried.
2-some hindus must be given devi devta status by hindu dharma sansad . they will hv killer weapons and atuority to kill the veil on the spot.
this will make the bharat crime free.
3- hindus must get free shiksha to any level in gurukul paddhatti. hindu girls n boys must stay not in malls but in gurukuls up to minimum 25 years of age in brham charya ashram
4-hindus must get yog shalas, dhyan yog shala , dharm shala n gaushala free of cost.
5- hindus must get free sanskaar service . pundits must be paid by govt n should get all havan samgri from govt expenses n other facilities such as bhajn mandli , decoration , furniture , prasad distribution etc
6- garbhdan , nam karan sanskar to antyeshti sanskaar is hindu relious right n it should be given to each hindu fom govt.
7- hindus must be given free ayurvedic treatment for all kinds of sickness.
8 hindus must get gau milk free or low cost at least half liter per person per day other religions must be banned from these facilities because these are not in their religions.
vhp n all hindu organisations must unite hindus and get all these n more religious rights of hindus.
otherwise topple this govts n bring a full majority national govt which can restore hindu religious rights straight away.
foreign religions must get only those rights in india which hindus get in foreign religion coutry. for example muslims sgoud get only those rights which hindus get saudi arabia
n christians only those rights which hinuds get in rome. i.e at par

Monday, June 27, 2011

Ways to destroy Hindus

Textbooks teaching Secular Marxisim is objected by the Kerela church, this is a very important trend. Secular-Marxism is ONLY AN INTERIM STAGE in the thought pattern. Stage-1 is to de-Hinduize using secularism. But once Christianity (or Islam) in a certain location are sufficiently strong they will overthrow secular-Marxism as anti-religion. A good example is the last Hindu country to fall, Nepal it followed this pattern. Hindus are confused by SECULARISM which was solely designed against abuses by the Catholic Church in Europe ,but this then is applied in India to Hindu Dharama ( which is not a religion). Another example is Baba Ramdev his anti corruption fight is Dharmic the corrupt politicians are secular and they have no moral nor dharmic boundaries

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Panic and be dammed

अप्रतीकारेषु व्यसनेष्वनादरो न कर्तव्यः॥२५२॥
याते समुद्रेऽपि हि पोतभङ्गे सांयात्रिको वाञ्जति तर्त्तुमेव॥

apratīkāreṣu vyasaneṣvanādaro na kartavyaḥ||252||
||yāte samudre'pi hi potabhaṅge sāṁyātriko vāñjati tarttumeva||

Yet another sage advice from Chanakya
Even on the face of unbearable grief one should not lose his composure and relax his vigil.
As an illustration, it is said....if one has gone into the rough seas and the vessel is broken and gobbled up by the rough waves, still the sailor thinks of only reaching the shore by swimming or holding on to a floating log.

Whatever may be our conditions in life, our survival hinges on our grit... the refusal to give up at any cost. If a battle is lost in our mind, we can never win it in the field. We have to just proceed ahead because we are sure to find at least a little light at the farthest corner of the labyrinth. Once the mind and spirit give way to sorrow, we are defeated even before we take the first step in the rescue operation. History of humanity bear testimony to the ultimate success and happiness for the person with grit.. Take the case of Rama and Sita, the Pandavas, Nala and Damayanthi, Harischandra.. and in modern times the victory against nepotism and colonialism fought by the people of France, United States, our own India under the Mahatma, the wars fought by Churchill and Nelson and the movements of Castro and che Guevara ... True grit alone prevailed. And remember, the basic human nature is to panic when we are faced with adversities but we have no other choice other than make our mind as hard as steel and go and face the situation.

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Three facts about Islam for Non believers

Non believer (Kafirs) need to know some simple facts about Islam people assume Islam is just another religion like their own and this is a mistake take these 3 simple facts about Islam to show my point

1. Islam has not been hijacked. That Islam has been hijacked is what non-Muslims naturally assume because they assume all religions are the same. So they further assume that some crazies must have hijacked the religion because surely no religion would actually encourage the killing of innocents. We want to believe the religion has been hijacked. Once people realize it isn't true, we can start talking about real solutions.

2. Muslims are allowed to deceive non-Muslims if it helps Islam. The principle of taqiyya is surprising to non-Muslims. Knowing about the principle helps immunize non-Muslims from the deception. They can at least not take everything a Muslim leader says at face value. You can see (and share) some excellent examples of taqiyya in the movie, Obsession.

3. Striving to institute worldwide Shari'a law is a religious duty. Many people don't realize how politically-oriented Islam is at its core. Shari'a is the law of Allah. Any other form of government is a sin. It is their duty as a Muslim to keep striving until all governments have been converted to Shari'a law. I think when kafirs understand this, they will immediately grasp the basic principle that all governments must immediately stop all concessions to Islam

Monday, April 18, 2011

Mother Teresa

once made me cry. The year was 1988 - I was on one of my frequent holidays or visits to Calcutta from Britain, where I had moved to in 1985. I was standing by the kerb-side in Gariahat Morr, munching on a famous 'mutton roll'. I was looking at scenes I had grown up with - pavements almost obliterated by shops, people having to weave their way through hawkers peddling their fares; buses tilted to one side by the sheer weight of passengers and belching out black diesel smoke, trams waiting for a manual change of tracks before they could turn, the familiar neon sign of an astrologer.

In the midst of all this I remembered the 'Calcutta' of the West - Calcutta the metaphor, not the city. In my three years in the West I had come to realise that the city had become synonymous with the worst of human suffering and degradation in the eyes of the world. I read and heard again and again that Calcutta contained an endless number of 'sewers and gutters' where an endless number of dead and dying people lay - but not for long - as 'roving angels' in the shape of the followers of a certain nun would come along looking for them. Then they would whisk them away in their smart ambulances. As in my twenty-seven years in Calcutta I had never seen such a scene, (and neither have I met a Calcuttan who has), it hurt me deeply that such a wrong stereotype had become permanently ingrained in world psyche. I felt suddenly overwhelmingly sad that a city, indeed an entire culture should be continuously insulted in this way........see link

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Book "Breaking India"

NEW DELHI, January 11th, 2011 (By Rajiv Malik, HPI Correspondent) :

'It is a book intended to be an eye opener, a warning to us,' said jurist and former Law Minister of India, Shri Ram Jethamalani, while formally releasing the book 'Breaking India : Western Interventions in Dravidian and Dalit Faultlines.' The book is jointly authored by Rajiv Malhotra, head of Infinity Foundation and Aravindan Neelakandan, a popular science writer in Tamil.

Shri Ram Jethamalani continued, 'We have internal enemies enough but there are external enemies outside our borders who are collaborating with their dummies , agents and proxies inside our borders. And they are trying to achieve the result which is to weaken India, break its unity, break its integration and ultimately to jeopardize our freedom, our sovereignty and perhaps our culture.'

Or in other words: 'Why West Controls The Discourse On India ?' asks Rajiv Malhotra, the author of the book.

The book release function was held in New Delhi's Vivekananda International Foundation on Wednesday, February 9th, 2011. It was followed by a discussion on the book by Shri S. Gurumurthy, Public Intellectual ; Vice Admiral [Retd] Raman Puri and Dr. Upendra Baxi , Emeritus Professor of Law, University of Warwick.

In his keynote address, Shri Ram Jethamalani also stated, 'The authors have found out that there are three external dangers from which India is exposed in a very big way. The Islamic radicals which are operating from a neighboring country, perhaps from other countries too. Then there are Maoists and others who are being supported by Chinese. The third category is of the persons who are trying to create a new race of Dravidians and also taking in account the large number of what we call the dalits. They are trying to instigate a feeling of separatism and thereby further weaken this country.'

He went on to say, 'Sanskrit language in the past united the bonds between the north and the south of India. But today a move is on to remove Sanskrit words from the Tamil language, to make Tamil a separate language altogether not belonging to the group of languages which were sourced from Sanskrit. There are religious groups who are carrying on this false propaganda and this must be understood.'

In his presentation Shri S. Gurumurthy said, ' This work is long overdue. There have been a lot of efforts to expose the kind of machinations that are going on to pervert our nationalism, pervert our past, pervert our great heroes, pervert even our spiritual personalities like Thiruvalluvar. Questioning whether Thiruvalluvar was a Christian ? And the entire Saiva Siddhanta is being perverted as a by-product of Christianity. You can understand the extent of damage that this kind of perversion can cause in a society where there are no organized efforts to counter these things. We are not an organized society, that is our strength. We are not an organized society, that is our weakness. Organized societies collapse and collapse very easily. Societies which are not organized, like us, they do not collapse, they decay.'

He also added that the book is an intellectually sound documentation of the current state of affairs in the country and opens up a debate in the country. It is however, not trying to propagate any ideology [against Christianity] . The book focuses on Tamil Nadu and captures the various developments in the state; making it what it is today. The rapid conversion of poor dalits to Christianity by distorting the various Hindu teachings and facts is a current phenomena.

Vice Admiral [Retd] Raman Puri, in his speech said, 'De-sanskritisation of India is not new and has been happening since the time of the British Raj. We Indians are a victim to it. It is thereby important to stop this de-culturalisation and work towards restoring Indian culture, its values and it's very fabric which is under threat.' He finally said, 'Their [foreign countries] business is to keep us weak by annihilating our culture and our business is to keep it strong.'

Dr. Upendra Baxi warned the reader of the book that it is important to read and understand this book in the right light. He said that 'India has been suffering from three S's. Subordination [under British rule], subversion [of Indian culture , that is happening currently] and surveillance [under the strict watch of the West]. Given the Indian political context , the book is under the danger of being misread and thereby lead to the breaking of India. He pointed out that it is important that the book should neither be aligned to right wing ideology or left wing ideology, for here lies the threat of being misinterpreted. Instead he saw the book as a collection of 'unpleasant facts' that have been a part of the country for quite some time. Dr. Baxi ended his speech on a poignant note by raising a question as to how Mohan Das [Mohan Das Karamchand Gandhi] would have reacted to this book. This however , Dr. Baxi left open ended for every one to ponder.

In his speech author of the book Rajiv Malhotra pointed out that the book focused on the role of US and European churches, academics, think tanks, foundations, government and human rights groups in fostering separation of the identities of Dravidian and Dalit communities from the rest of India. The book, according to him was the result of five years of research which tracked the money trails that start out claiming to be for 'education', 'human rights', 'empowerment training' and 'leadership training', but end up programs designed to produce angry youths who feel disenfranchised from Indian identity.

Malhotra further stated that the book highlighted 'how the discourse on India at various levels is being increasingly controlled by the institutions in the West which in turn serve its geo-political ambitions. So, why has India failed to create its own institutions that are the equivalent of the Ford Foundation, Fullbright Foundation, Rockfeller Foundation etc. ?'

Raising some other pertinent questions he said, 'Why are there no Indian university based International Relations programs with deep-rooted links to the External Affairs Ministry and various cultural, historical and ideological think tanks ? Why are the most prestigious journals, university degrees and conferences on India Studies, in sharp contrast to the way China Studies worldwide is under the control of Chinese dominated discourse, based in the West and mostly under the control of western institutions